The black and white chart method is one of the most widely used visual procedures for determining the hiding power (opacity) of paints and coatings, expressed as the minimum mass of paint per square metre required to obscure a standard black and white contrast substrate. This article explains the technical principle, applicable standards, sample requirements, test procedure, calculation, and typical applications of the method, providing a practical reference for manufacturers, formulators, and accredited third-party laboratories.
Technical Overview
Hiding power, also referred to as opacity or covering power, describes the ability of a paint film to eliminate the color or color differences of the substrate over which it is applied. It is a fundamental performance property for architectural, industrial, and decorative coatings because it directly determines how much paint must be applied to achieve a uniform appearance, and it strongly influences formulation cost, particularly the loading of titanium dioxide and other opacifying pigments.
The black and white chart method (also called the black and white grid or checkerboard method) is a gravimetric-visual technique in which paint is applied to a standardized checkerboard panel consisting of alternating black and white squares. The operator applies paint progressively until the contrast between the black and white squares is just no longer visible under specified observation conditions. By weighing the quantity of paint consumed and dividing it by the area covered, the hiding power is calculated and expressed in grams per square metre (g/m²). A lower value indicates better hiding performance.
The classical version of the method is described in the Chinese national standard GB/T 1726 (Determination of hiding power of paint films), which specifies both a brush-out method and a spray application method. Related international approaches include ISO 2814 and ISO 6504-1, ASTM D344 (visual comparison of relative hiding power), and ASTM D2805 (instrumental hiding power by reflectometry). These methods differ in substrate geometry and measurement principle, but all quantify the same fundamental property.
Testing Samples
Waterborne Architectural Coatings
Emulsion-based interior and exterior wall paints, latex paints, and flat, eggshell, or semi-gloss finishes are the most frequently tested product category. These coatings are typically evaluated to verify pigment volume concentration design and titanium dioxide efficiency.
Solvent-Borne Coatings
Alkyd enamels, chlorinated rubber paints, nitrocellulose lacquers, and other solvent-based finishes can be tested using the same checkerboard principle, with adjustment of application technique and drying conditions to match the product system.
Primers, Undercoats, and Sealers
Hiding performance is critical for primers designed to block stains or uniformize absorbent or contrasting substrates. The black and white chart method provides a direct visual index of this blocking capability.
Sample Preparation Requirements
- Sample quantity: typically 100 g to 500 g of homogeneous, representative material taken from a production batch or submission container.
- Conditioning: samples are usually stored at 23 ± 2 °C for at least 16 hours before testing to ensure stable viscosity and application behavior.
- Pre-treatment: paints are thoroughly stirred or tumbled to redisperse settled pigment, with care taken to avoid entraining air bubbles.
- Documentation: batch number, production date, product type, and declared contrast ratio or spreading rate should accompany the sample.
Testing Items
The core deliverable of the test is the hiding power value in g/m², representing the minimum paint consumption per unit area needed to fully obscure the black and white contrast pattern. Depending on client requirements and product specifications, laboratories may also report the following related items:
- Minimum wet film thickness at the hiding end point, calculated from consumption and paint density.
- Theoretical spreading rate (m²/kg or m²/L) corresponding to the hiding end point.
- Contrast ratio at a fixed spreading rate, when the photometric procedure of ISO 2814 or GB/T 9755 / GB/T 9756 product standards is applied in parallel.
- Surface appearance observations, such as leveling defects, flooding, or floating that interfere with the visual end point.
Testing Methods
Apparatus and Materials
- A black and white checkerboard panel, classically a glass plate of approximately 100 mm × 200 mm, divided into 25 mm × 25 mm alternating black and white squares, with black and white areas of equal size and a known total test area.
- A soft bristle brush or a spray gun capable of producing a uniform fine atomization.
- An analytical balance with a resolution of 0.01 g or better.
- A stopwatch, film thickness gauge, and a conditioned test environment at 23 ± 2 °C and 50 ± 5 % relative humidity.
- A controlled light source providing diffuse daylight-equivalent illumination without glare or shadow on the panel.
Brush-Out Method (Method A)
The brush and paint container are weighed together before application. Paint is then brushed onto the checkerboard in overlapping strokes, working from one end and covering a measured portion of the grid. The end point is reached when the boundary between black and white squares can no longer be distinguished by normal vision at a viewing distance of approximately 300 to 500 mm. The brush and container are reweighed, and the mass difference gives the paint consumed. If full hiding is achieved only over part of the panel, the covered area is measured and used in the calculation.
Spray Method (Method B)
For spray-applicable coatings, the weighed paint is sprayed onto the vertically or horizontally held checkerboard in thin, uniform passes, allowing flash-off between passes. Spraying continues until the black and white contrast just disappears. The mass of paint consumed is obtained by weighing the spray apparatus before and after application, and the calculation follows the same principle as the brush method.
Calculation
The hiding power is calculated as: Hiding power (g/m²) = mass of paint applied at the hiding end point (g) ÷ area of checkerboard fully hidden (m²). When partial coverage is used, only the hidden area is entered in the denominator. Results are typically reported as the average of at least two, preferably three, determinations, together with the test method, drying conditions, and observation lighting.
Key Factors Affecting Accuracy
- Uniformity of film build and operator technique, which strongly influence the visual end point in the brush method.
- Illumination intensity and direction, and the observer's angle of view, which must be standardized and documented.
- Paint temperature and viscosity at the time of application.
- Contrast quality of the checkerboard, including cleanliness and geometric accuracy of the black and white squares.
- Slow-drying or high-solids systems, where wet and dry hiding differ; the end point is judged on the dry film unless otherwise specified.
Applications
Black and white chart hiding power data support a wide range of practical decisions across the coatings industry:
- Quality control of production batches, confirming consistency of pigment dispersion and tinting strength against internal limits.
- Formulation optimization, including titanium dioxide level, extender selection, and pigment volume concentration studies, where reduced g/m² values translate directly into raw material savings.
- Product comparison and benchmarking during research and development or competitive analysis.
- Verification against product standard requirements, such as those in GB/T 9755 and GB/T 9756 for exterior and interior emulsion wall coatings, where hiding-related limits ensure field performance.
- Procurement and acceptance testing by contractors, distributors, and owners who require documented opacity evidence from accredited third-party laboratories.
- Technical data sheet development, converting laboratory hiding values into recommended spreading rates and practical coverage figures for end users.
FAQ
What does a hiding power result of, for example, 120 g/m² mean?
It means that 120 grams of that paint, applied uniformly, are just sufficient to hide a black and white contrast substrate over one square metre. Lower values indicate more efficient opacity and potentially lower material consumption per job.
Is a lower or higher g/m² value better?
Lower is better. A lower value means less paint is required to achieve complete hiding, which improves economy and reduces application time.
How does the black and white chart method differ from the contrast ratio method?
The chart method is a gravimetric visual test that yields consumption in g/m² at the just-hidden end point, and it depends on controlled operator observation. The contrast ratio method, described in ISO 2814 and related standards, measures the reflectance of a film applied at a fixed rate over black and white substrates using a reflectometer, giving an instrumental percentage. The two results are related but not directly interchangeable.
Which standard governs the test?
The classical black and white grid procedure is specified in GB/T 1726. Internationally, ISO 2814, ISO 6504-1, ASTM D344, and ASTM D2805 cover comparable hiding power determinations using visual or photometric principles.
What types of paint are not suitable for this method?
Very fast-drying coatings, textured or heavily filled materials, and clear coatings with no intrinsic opacity are poorly suited. For such systems, instrumental reflectance methods or wet hiding assessment on special charts are more appropriate.
How long does a typical test take?
A single determination usually takes one to two hours, including weighing, application, drying to the evaluation state, and calculation. Full reporting with replicate determinations is commonly completed within one working day.
Why Choose ZKGX?
- State-of-the-art analytical equipment
- Highly qualified scientific team
- Fast turnaround time
- Competitive pricing