ASTM G28 is the internationally recognized standard test method for detecting susceptibility to intergranular corrosion in stainless steels and nickel-bearing alloys. This article provides a comprehensive technical overview of ASTM G28 Method A and Method B, covering applicable materials, test specimens, testing procedures, result evaluation, and typical industrial applications.
Technical Overview
ASTM G28, titled "Standard Test Methods for Detecting Susceptibility to Intergranular Corrosion in Stainless Steels and Nickel-Bearing Alloys," establishes two accelerated laboratory procedures for evaluating whether a material is susceptible to intergranular attack. Intergranular corrosion is a localized form of degradation that occurs along grain boundaries when chromium-rich carbides precipitate during improper heat treatment, slow cooling, or welding, creating chromium-depleted zones that are preferentially attacked in corrosive environments.
The standard includes two distinct boiling-acid test methods. Method A, the ferric sulfate–sulfuric acid test, is designed for stainless steels and nickel-chromium-iron alloys. Method B, a more aggressive mixed-acid test, was developed specifically for highly alloyed corrosion-resistant nickel-based materials such as those containing high levels of molybdenum and chromium. Both methods evaluate susceptibility by measuring mass loss over a defined exposure period and, where required, by subsequent bend testing or metallographic examination.
ASTM G28 testing is widely specified in material procurement standards such as ASTM B575, B625, and B626, and is routinely performed by accredited third-party laboratories as part of quality control, welding procedure qualification, and failure analysis programs.
Testing Samples
Austenitic Stainless Steels and Ni-Cr-Fe Alloys (Method A)
Method A applies to austenitic stainless steels and related nickel-bearing alloys whose corrosion resistance depends on chromium. Typical materials include:
- Austenitic stainless steels such as UNS S30400, S31600, S31700, S32100, and S34700
- Super-austenitic grades such as UNS N08904 (904L) and N08367 (6MO)
- Nickel-chromium-iron alloys such as UNS N08800 and N08810 (Alloy 800/800H)
- Nickel-iron-chromium-molybdenum alloys such as UNS N08020 (Alloy 20) and N08825 (Alloy 825)
Highly Alloyed Nickel-Based Materials (Method B)
Method B was developed for alloys whose high molybdenum and chromium content makes them too corrosion resistant for meaningful evaluation in the Method A solution within a practical time frame. Typical materials include:
- UNS N10276 (Alloy C-276)
- UNS N06022 (Alloy C-22)
- UNS N06455 (Alloy C-4)
- UNS N06059 (Alloy 59)
- UNS N06625 (Alloy 625)
Product Forms and Specimen Preparation
Test specimens may be taken from plate, sheet, strip, bar, forgings, castings, pipe, and tubing, as well as from welded joints and heat-affected zones. Prior to testing, specimens are machined to the dimensions specified in the standard, degreased, cleaned of all scale and oxide, dimensioned for surface area calculation, and weighed to the required precision. The exposed surface area of each specimen must be accurately determined because it is used directly in the corrosion rate calculation. An adequate solution volume-to-surface-area ratio must be maintained in accordance with the standard.
Testing Items
ASTM G28 testing typically includes the following evaluations:
- Mass loss determination of each specimen after the boiling acid exposure
- Calculation of the corrosion rate in millimeters per year (mm/y) or mils per year (mpy)
- Bend testing of exposed specimens to reveal intergranular cracking
- Metallographic cross-sectional examination to measure the depth and morphology of intergranular attack
- Comparison of measured corrosion rates against the acceptance limits of the applicable material specification
- Optional evaluation of sensitized or as-welded conditions versus solution-annealed reference conditions
Testing Methods
Method A – Ferric Sulfate–Sulfuric Acid Test
In Method A, weighed specimens are immersed in a boiling solution consisting of ferric sulfate dissolved in a 50% sulfuric acid solution. The test is conducted in a glass flask fitted with a reflux condenser so that the solution remains at a constant boiling temperature throughout the exposure. The standard exposure period is 120 hours. The ferric sulfate acts as an oxidizing agent that maintains a corrosion potential at which chromium-depleted grain boundaries are selectively attacked, while the bulk of a properly heat-treated alloy remains passive.
After exposure, the specimens are cleaned, dried, and reweighed. The mass loss is converted to a corrosion rate, and the result is compared with the maximum permissible value stated in the relevant product specification.
Method B – Mixed-Acid Test
Method B exposes weighed specimens to a boiling solution containing approximately 23% sulfuric acid, 1.2% hydrochloric acid, ferric sulfate, and cupric sulfate. This more aggressive chemistry, combined with the presence of chlorides, provides a discriminating evaluation for highly alloyed nickel materials in a shorter standard exposure period of 24 hours. As in Method A, evaluation is performed by mass loss measurement and corrosion rate calculation, supplemented by bend testing or metallographic examination where specified.
Evaluation and Calculation of Results
The corrosion rate is calculated from the measured mass loss using the following relationship:
CR (mm/y) = (8.76 × 10⁴ × W) / (A × T × D), where W is the mass loss in grams, A is the total exposed surface area in square centimeters, T is the exposure time in hours, and D is the material density in grams per cubic centimeter. Acceptance criteria are defined by the governing material specifications rather than by ASTM G28 itself. For example, procurement standards for nickel alloy plate commonly impose a maximum allowable corrosion rate that the delivered material must not exceed.
Bend testing after acid exposure provides a qualitative pass/fail assessment: the presence of cracks or fissures on the tension surface of a bent specimen indicates intergranular attack. Metallographic examination confirms whether the observed attack is genuinely intergranular and quantifies its depth.
Applications
ASTM G28 testing supports material qualification and integrity management across many demanding industries:
- Chemical and petrochemical processing: qualification of reactors, heat exchangers, and piping in hot acid service
- Oil and gas: evaluation of corrosion-resistant alloy tubing, clad plate, and weld overlays in sour and acidic environments
- Flue gas desulfurization: verification of high-nickel alloy scrubber components exposed to acidic chloride media
- Pharmaceutical and fine chemical manufacturing: material certification for equipment contact surfaces
- Nuclear and power generation: assessment of sensitization in components subject to thermal exposure
- Pulp and paper: qualification of alloys in chloride-containing process liquors
- Welding procedure qualification: confirmation that welding does not produce sensitized heat-affected zones
- Failure analysis: determination of whether intergranular attack contributed to in-service cracking or leakage
FAQ
What is the difference between ASTM G28 Method A and Method B?
Method A uses a boiling ferric sulfate–50% sulfuric acid solution with a 120-hour exposure and is intended for stainless steels and nickel-chromium-iron alloys. Method B uses a more aggressive boiling mixture of sulfuric acid, hydrochloric acid, ferric sulfate, and cupric sulfate with a 24-hour exposure and is intended for highly alloyed nickel-based materials such as Alloy C-276 and Alloy C-22, which would show negligible attack in the Method A solution within a practical test duration.
How does ASTM G28 differ from ASTM A262?
ASTM A262 covers practices specifically for detecting intergranular corrosion susceptibility in austenitic stainless steels and includes several practices such as the oxalic acid etch, nitric acid (Huey), ferric sulfate–sulfuric acid, and copper–copper sulfate–16% sulfuric acid tests. ASTM G28 extends this type of evaluation to nickel-bearing alloys and is the standard of choice for nickel-based materials, with Method B providing a test tailored to the most highly alloyed grades.
What causes intergranular corrosion susceptibility in these alloys?
Susceptibility is primarily caused by sensitization, the precipitation of chromium-rich carbides at grain boundaries during exposure to temperatures of roughly 425 to 815 °C. This may result from slow cooling after hot working, stress relieving, improper solution annealing, multi-pass welding, or long-term service at elevated temperatures. The carbide precipitation depletes chromium in the adjacent grain boundary regions, leaving them unable to form a protective passive film.
How long does an ASTM G28 test take?
The acid exposure itself requires 120 hours for Method A and 24 hours for Method B. Total turnaround time also includes specimen machining, conditioning and sensitization heat treatment if required, pre-test cleaning and weighing, post-test evaluation, and metallographic or bend examination. In practice, a complete test program typically takes one to two weeks depending on the scope.
What sample size is required for testing?
Specimen dimensions are defined in the standard and are based on the available product form and thickness. Coupons with a precisely measurable surface area are machined from the material, and sufficient solution volume per specimen is maintained as required by the method. For welded material, the specimen is oriented so that the weld and heat-affected zone are fully exposed to the test solution.
How are test results interpreted?
Results are interpreted by comparing the calculated corrosion rate with the maximum acceptance limit in the applicable material specification, such as those referenced in ASTM procurement standards for nickel alloy plate, sheet, and tubing. Corrosion rates above the limit, intergranular cracks found in bend testing, or measurable grain boundary attack in metallographic examination indicate that the material is sensitized and susceptible to intergranular corrosion. Remedies typically include proper solution annealing, use of low-carbon or stabilized grades, or control of welding heat input.
Why Choose ZKGX?
- State-of-the-art analytical equipment
- Highly qualified scientific team
- Fast turnaround time
- Competitive pricing